Definitions before dollars
A few years ago, I started asking every healthcare CFO the same question in our first meeting.
"When your strategic plan says you're going to do something, what's the process that makes sure it actually happens?"
Most of the time, I get a pause. Then some version of "we have monthly financial reviews."
The strategic plan lives in a binder. The budget lives in a spreadsheet. And the space between them is where accountability goes to die.
This issue is about the spreadsheet. Not the dollars in it. What sits underneath them.
Issue 1 asked who owns the number after the outside team leaves. Issue 2 asked what a rate is built on before you sign. The belief I'm working from this month hasn't changed: a result keeps working only if a missed number leads to a real change.
Here's the catch. You can't change anything because a number missed if nobody agreed on what the number was counting.
1. A budget is a set of definitions
A budget is a set of definitions before it is a set of dollars.
Every figure in it rests on quieter answers. Who is counted. Where. Starting from when. Those answers decide the number before anyone types it in.
So when a payer leaves a shared budget, do not argue the rate first. Interrogate the definitions underneath it: the population, the market area, and the base year.
Capital works the same way. I once sorted a hospital capital plan into four buckets: Replace, Comply, Absorb, Grow. Only one of them is truly a choice. Sorting doesn't move a single dollar. It changes which dollars are actually up for a decision.
2. Three definitions to interrogate
The population. Who is in the count, and who is out of it. If that isn't written down so nobody can argue about what it means, the argument hasn't been avoided. It's been scheduled for later.
The market area. Your market is almost never yours alone. Whoever draws the service area decides who gets credit for growth, and who gets blamed when it shrinks.
The base year. In the first issue I wrote that, too often, no one wrote down the numbers before anything changed. Everyone was too busy starting. If the starting point has to be rebuilt, rebuild it from your own records and say so at the top of the page. Better to be believed than impressive.
3. Temporary money
There's one more thing to check in the base year.
Temporary money has a habit of becoming permanent, then becoming a fight.
If a fund started as an emergency, ask what happens when the emergency ends, before you build it into your base. Once it's in the base, it stops looking like a one-time dollar. It looks like the starting point. And whoever inherits that starting point inherits the fight.
4. Own the definitions before the number misses
Here's where this month's belief comes back in.
If those definitions were never settled, the first meeting after a miss isn't about what to change. It's about what the number meant. Was the population right? Who drew the market? Was that year ever a fair place to start? Each of those questions can become a way to not decide.
The fix is to settle them before the miss, and to give each one an owner. A committee can advise. A committee cannot own. Decision rights have to live with a name, not a table.
Before you sign the next budget number, answer four things in writing:
- The population. Who is counted? State it so nobody can argue about what it means.
- The market area. Who drew it, and who gets the credit or the blame when it moves?
- The base year. Where does the number start, was it rebuilt, and is any temporary money sitting in it?
- The owner. Who owns each definition, and who decides when one has to change? A name, not a table.
I wrote this about capital plans, and it holds here too: any question you can't answer in a sentence is the work to do before the vote, not after.
That's what lets a missed number show up already carrying its next move. Nobody spends the first meeting arguing about what the number meant. They spend it deciding what changes.
Think about the next budget number you'll be asked to sign. Who did it count, where, and starting when? And whose name is on each of those answers?
If this was useful, forward it to someone who signs budgets, or subscribe so the next issue comes straight to you.
James